One
of my favorite things to bake is cookies but, most of my favorite
recipes make 3 or 4 or more dozen cookies. Not really practical if
only one or two people are trying to eat them. You either are soo
bored of the cookies by the time you finish the batch or they become
so stale you end up tossing them. Or you gorge on them and eat way
too many the day you made them. In any case making 36 or so cookies
just doesn't work for the small household.
That
is the very reason I started tracking down some basic small batch
cookie recipes which I have been playing with to replicate the
cookies I already love to bake. My main rule is that the recipe can
make no more than 12 cookies. The first cookie recipe I have for you
is my Oatmeal M&M Cookies. We love this recipe and I think it
turns out better than my original one that made a huge batch. This
recipe makes between 9 and 11 cookies for me, depending on how big I
make them.
On
the subject of how big to make them, I started using a cookie scoop
years ago and I always portion my cookie dough this way. Basically a
cookie scoop is a small ice cream scoop. My favorite one holds just
about a Tablespoon if you fill it level with the edge. For most
cookies I scoop a bit more than what fits in the scoop, kind of like
I do when I scoop ice cream with my larger scoop. If you don't
already have one of these scoops I do recommend going out to find
one.
The
other thing I find especially useful in baking on a small scale is a
set of measuring spoons that includes an 1/8 teaspoon. I really find
this to be a necessary tool in my small scale baking.
So
let's get to this recipe.
Oatmeal
M&M Cookies
3
tablespoons butter (the real stuff, salted) softened
3
tablespoons dark brown sugar
1
tablespoon granulated sugar
1
egg yolk
½
teaspoon vanilla extract
1/3
cup all purpose flour
¼
teaspoon baking soda
1/8
teaspoon salt (since I only use Kosher salt I use a heaped 1/8
teaspoon)
½
cup old fashioned rolled oats (quick oats will work but I prefer the
texture of the old fashioned)
1
(3.14 oz) package M&M's- mine was labeled as “sharing size”
Pre-heat
your oven to 350°F.
Line
a cookie sheet with parchment paper.
In
a medium size bowl cream the butter and the sugars together until
light and fluffy using a hand held mixer.
Add
the egg yolk and vanilla and mix until well combined.
In
a small bowl combine the flour, baking soda and salt. Stir well to
combine then add to the butter/sugar mixture. Mix until everything is
well combined.
Add
the oatmeal and M&Ms and stir just until well combined. This step
is best done by hand so you don't break up the candy pieces.
Using
a cookie scoop or spoons, scoop the cookie dough onto the parchment
lined cookie sheet. Bake for around 10 minutes, until the cookies are
just browning. 10 minutes is how long my oven takes, yours may vary
so you should probably check at 9 minutes and know it might take up
to 11 minutes all together to cook in your oven.
Leave
on the hot cookie sheet to cool for 5 minutes then move to a cooling
rack until completely cooled.
Now
sit back with a nice hot cup of your favorite beverage (mine is
coffee) and enjoy a couple of those wonderful cookies while they are
still warm.